Solutions
Solutions for
K-12
K-12
Learn MoreEducator & Staff Training
Educator & Staff Training
Improve compliance and deliver critical professional development with online courses and management system
Learn moreStudent Safety & Wellness Program NEW
Student Safety & Wellness Program
Keep students safe and healthy with safety, well-being, and social and emotional learning courses and lessons
Learn moreProfessional Growth Management
Professional Growth Management
Integrated software to manage and track evaluations and professional development and deliver online training
Learn moreAnonymous Reporting & Safety Communications
Anonymous Reporting & Safety Communications
Empower your school community to ask for help to improve school safety and prevent crises before they occur
Learn moreIncident & EHS Management
Incident & EHS Management
Streamline safety incident reporting and management to improve safety, reduce risk, and increase compliance
Learn moreHigher Education
Higher Education
Learn MoreStudent Training
Student Training
Increase safety, well-being, and belonging with proven-effective training on critical prevention topics
Learn moreFaculty & Staff Training
Faculty & Staff Training
Create a safe, healthy, and welcoming campus environment and improve compliance with online training courses
Learn moreCampus Climate Surveys
Campus Climate Surveys
Simplify VAWA compliance with easy, scalable survey deployment, tracking, and reporting
Learn moreAnonymous Reporting & Safety Communications
Anonymous Reporting & Safety Communications
Empower your faculty, staff, and students to take an active role in protecting themselves and others
Learn moreIncident & EHS Management
Incident & EHS Management
Streamline safety incident reporting and management to improve safety, reduce risk, and increase compliance
Learn moreManufacturing
Manufacturing
Learn MoreSafety Training NEW
Safety Training
Elevate performance and productivity while reducing risk across your entire organization with online training.
Learn moreIndustrial Skills Training NEW
Industrial Skills Training
Close skills gap, maximize production, and drive consistency with online training
Learn morePaper Manufactuing Training
Paper Manufactuing Training
Enhance worker expertise and problem-solving skills while ensuring optimal production efficiency.
Learn moreHR & Compliance
Provide role-specific knowledge, develop skills, and improve employee retention with career development training.
Learning Management System (LMS)
Learning Management System (LMS)
Assign, track, and report role-based skills and compliance training for the entire workforce
Learn moreEHS Management
EHS Management
Track, Analyze, Report Health and Safety Activities and Data for the Industrial Workforce
Learn moreSafety Communication
Safety Communication
Enhance the safety for the industrial workforce with two-way risk communications, tools, and resources
Learn moreFire Departments
Fire Departments
Learn MoreTraining Management
Training Management
A training management system tailored for the fire service--track all training, EMS recerts, skill evaluations, ISO, and more in one place
Learn moreCrew Shift Scheduling
Crew Shift Scheduling
Simplify 24/7 staffing and give firefighters the convenience of accepting callbacks and shifts from a mobile device
Learn moreChecks & Inventory Management
Checks & Inventory Management
Streamline truck checks, PPE inspections, controlled substance tracking, and equipment maintenance with a convenient mobile app
Learn moreExposure and Critical Incident Monitoring NEW
Exposure and Critical Incident Monitoring
Document exposures and critical incidents and protect your personnels’ mental and physical wellness
Learn moreEMS
EMS
Learn MoreTraining Management and Recertification
Training Management and Recertification
A training management system tailored for EMS services—EMS online courses for recerts, mobile-enabled skill evaluations, and more
Learn moreEMS Shift Scheduling
EMS Shift Scheduling
Simplify 24/7 staffing and give medics the convenience of managing their schedules from a mobile device
Learn moreInventory Management
Inventory Management
Streamline vehicle checks, controlled substance tracking, and equipment maintenance with a convenient mobile app
Learn moreWellness Monitoring & Exposure Tracking NEW
Wellness Monitoring & Exposure Tracking
Document exposures and critical incidents and protect your personnels’ mental and physical wellness
Learn moreLaw Enforcement
Law Enforcement
Learn MoreTraining and FTO Management
Training and FTO Management
Increase performance, reduce risk, and ensure compliance with a training management system tailored for your FTO/PTO and in-service training
Learn moreEarly Intervention & Performance Management
Early Intervention & Performance Management
Equip leaders with a tool for performance management and early intervention that helps build positive agency culture
Learn moreOfficer Shift Scheduling
Officer Shift Scheduling
Simplify 24/7 staffing and give officers the convenience of managing their schedules from a mobile device
Learn moreAsset Mangagement & Inspections
Asset Mangagement & Inspections
Streamline equipment checks and vehicle maintenance to ensure everything is working correctly and serviced regularly
Learn moreEnergy
Learn MoreSafety Training
Safety Training
Elevate performance and productivity while reducing risk across your entire organization with online training.
Learn moreEnergy Skills Training
Energy Skills Training
Empower your team with skills and safety training to ensure compliance and continuous advancement.
Learn moreHR & Compliance
Provide role-specific knowledge, develop skills, and improve employee retention with career development training.
Learning Management System (LMS)
Learning Management System (LMS)
Assign, track, and report role-based skills and compliance training for the entire workforce
Learn moreEHS Management
EHS Management
Track, analyze, report health and safety activities and data for the industrial workforce
Learn moreLone Worker Safety
Lone Worker Safety
Enhance lone worker safety with two way risk communications, tools, and resources
Learn moreGovernment
Learn MoreFederal Training Management
Federal Training Management
Lower training costs and increase readiness with a unified system designed for high-risk, complex training and compliance operations.
Learn moreMilitary Training Management
Military Training Management
Increase mission-readiness and operational efficiency with a unified system that optimizes military training and certification operations.
Learn moreLocal Government Training Management
Local Government Training Management
Technology to train, prepare, and retain your people
Learn moreFire Marshall Training & Compliance
Fire Marshall Training & Compliance
Improve fire service certification and renewal operations to ensure compliance and a get a comprehensive single source of truth.
Learn moreFire Academy Automation
Fire Academy Automation
Elevate fire academy training with automation software, enhancing efficiency and compliance.
Learn morePOST Training & Compliance
POST Training & Compliance
Streamline your training and standards operations to ensure compliance and put an end to siloed data.
Learn moreLaw Enforcement Academy Automation
Law Enforcement Academy Automation
Modernize law enforcement training with automation software that optimizing processes and centralizes academy information in one system.
Learn moreEHS Management
EHS Management
Simplify incident reporting to OSHA and reduce risk with detailed investigation management.
Learn moreArchitecture, Engineering & Construction
Architecture, Engineering & Construction
Learn MoreLearning Management System (LMS)
Learning Management System (LMS)
Ensure licensed professionals receive compliance and CE training via online courses and learning management.
Learn moreOnline Continuing Education
Online Continuing Education
Keep AEC staff licensed in all 50 states for 100+ certifications with online training
Learn moreTraining
Training
Drive organizational success with training that grows skills and aligns with the latest codes and standards
Learn moreEHS Management
EHS Management
Track, Analyze, Report Health and Safety Activities and Data for AEC Worksites
Learn moreHR & Compliance
HR & Compliance
Provide role-specific knowledge, develop skills, and improve employee retention with career development training.
Safety Communication
Safety Communication
Enhance AEC workforce safety with two-way risk communications, tools, and resources
Learn moreCasino
Casino
Learn MoreAnti-Money Laundering Training
Anti-Money Laundering Training
Reduce risk in casino operations with Title 31 and Anti-Money Laundering training compliance
Learn moreEmployee Training
Employee Training
Deliver our leading AML and casino-specific online courses to stay compliant with national and state standards
Learn moreLearning Management System (LMS)
Learning Management System (LMS)
Streamline training operations, increase employee effectiveness, and reduce liability with our LMS for casinos
Learn moreEHS Management
EHS Management
Simplify incident reporting to OSHA and reduce risk with detailed investigation management
Learn moreEmployee Scheduling
Employee Scheduling
Equip your employees with a mobile app to manage their schedules and simplify your 24/7 staff scheduling
Learn moreIndustries
Industry
Resources
Resource Center
Expert insights to boost training
Resource type
Course Catalogs
Company
Course Center
In this article, the continuation of our series of interviews with noted learning researcher Dr. Will Thalheimer, we’re going to discuss evidence-based training methods and learning myths with no supporting evidence.
The focus on evidence-based training methods is central to Dr. Thalheimer’s career and work, and it’s been the central focus of our earlier articles with him, which looked at smile sheets, spaced learning, and elearning effectiveness.
In this article, you’ll read about three three models for applying evidence-based training, about some learning methods that many think are proven and effective despite a lack of evidence supporting that, and about the importance of fighting the good fight to identify and use learning methods that truly support the learner.
And since this is the final article in the four-article series, we’d like to issue a big thank you to Dr. Thalheimer for his time and knowledge, both of which have been greatly appreciated. Don’t forget to check out his new model for learning evaluation, which he finished while we were writing this series. Maybe he’ll be nice enough to come back and discuss that with us in the future.
Convergence Training are workforce training experts.
Click the links below to learn more about how we can help you.
Convergence Training: I think a focus of your career, if it’s fair for me to state what your focus is, but clearly one of them is evidence-based training and learning methods, and in that line I’m a big fan of what you call training maximizers, which is maybe the same thing you referred to as the decisive dozen in our earlier interview on the effectiveness of elearning. Could you tell us about your training maximizers and the decisive dozen, and clear up any mistakes I may have just introduced by talking off the top of my head?
Dr. Will Thalheimer: They’re a little bit different. The decisive dozen are learning factors you can use in the design of learning, and the training maximizers model (which I’ve begun to call the learning maximizers model as well), is sort of the goals, the things we ought to aim for when we are designing our training and learning intervention.
There are 7 learning maximizers:
I created this several years ago, and as time goes on, I refer to that model more and more. I really like it.
The first is we ought have valid, credible content. The second one is the learning events ought to be engaging. And the third is the learners ought to understand the learning. Now we tend to be pretty good at those three.
It’s the next four that we’re not so good at. And that’s supporting long-term remembering, helping workers make decisions, persevering in learning, and and supporting remembering. Those are the ones we tend not to be as good at.
So the model is a really good reminder of things that we ought to be doing and yet don’t always do.
Note: Also see Dr. Thalheimer’s 4 Pillars of Training Effectiveness and Decisive Dozen Learning Methods.
Convergence Training: Great, a good reminder. And the 7 learning maximizers model sits nicely along your 4 pillars of instruction model (also discussed here) and your decisive dozen learning methods model (also discussed here). Now, the flip side of that is you do a lot of work, and in particular are often quite funny–as you often are in your work in general–in your debunker club and in exposing some common learning myths. Could you maybe name a few learning myths, things many people believe about learning even though there’s no evidence for them?
Dr. Will Thalhimer: Sure.
Well, the biggest one of the last few years is learning styles. A lot of people think that you ought to design our learning based on the learning style of our learner. But there have been many, many research studies over the years that show that’s an ineffective methodology, that we ought to be focused on learning factors, for example the learning factors in the decisive dozen.
A big one now is neuroscience. A lot of people think that brain science, neuroscience–that’s the place where we have the most wisdom about how to design learning. But neuroscience has added very little to what we know in terms of basic research–cognitive science, behavioral science. And so there’s a lot of commercial interests out there, vendors getting our attention out there, saying it’s all about neuroscience. But we are being fooled, it’s the new shiny object in our field, and so that’s a big myth, that neuroscience is ready. Some day it may be, but it’s certainly not yet.
Convergence Training: And how much of that do you attribute to straight-up scamming and snake oil, and how much do you attribute to people being confused about the difference between neuroscience and cognitive science?
Dr. Will Thalheimer: Uh…I’d say, well, I don’t know if I want to put a number on it, but most of it is snake oil. People just come up with stuff, they’ve been asked to compile research that will show learning in a good light and get eyeballs, so they compile everything they see and they don’t know what they’re doing. So some of it is unintentional, because humans tend to be interested in what is new, but there are definitely people taking advantage, too. Because I’ve talked to people and I’ve said “Hey, what you’re saying is not true, stop saying it” and some of them will change, but a lot of them don’t listen.
It’s a problem in our field, but it’s not new. There have always been fads that have come and gone. It’s something that we as learning professionals ought to know about our field. We ought to hold a certain healthy skepticism, we ought to look for people who are the research to practice practitioners…my work, Julie Dirksen, Patti Shank, Clark Quinn, Mirjam Neelan, some of the researchers who have reached out, Paul Kirschner, others making things practical. There is a lot of good stuff out there, but there’s also a lot of bad stuff, so it really behooves us as learning professionals to be active with those who are bridging the gap between research and practice.
Quick tip: Read more about learning myths here.
Convergence Training: Great, thanks. I’d also like to share a little information about yourself, your work, and your Will at Work blog. Anything you’d like to tell us?
Dr. Thalheimer: Well, you know, I am the most charming, lovely person in the field (laughs), hands down. The most handsome. I have the best set of abs. I mean, really.
Well, no. To be serious now, what I’ve tried to do for the last twenty years is to bridge the gap between the research side and the practice side, and spend a lot of time every year reading the scientific journals, and making sense of them, trying to cut through the jargon and the theoretical baggage, trying to find out what causes what, and then sharing that in the publications that I write, in my conference presentations, and my work with clients. It’s a joy to be able to do it, it’s a little bit of a Sisyphean task, because people don’t really pay for research, they pay for other things, so you’ll notice there aren’t a lot of us doing it out there, because it’s difficult. But I enjoy it, and it’s sort of my life’s work, and I am going to keep at it as long as I can.
Hope you found this article helpful.
If there’s one overarching tip we’re hoping you’ll take from this part of our interview with Dr. Thalheimer, it’s to use training methods that are proven to be effective in workforce learning & development efforts.
We’ve given you some specific examples of proven effective methods, as well as some examples of common myths that people in training often believe without seeing the evidence or analyzing it closely. And from there, we encourage you to continue the evaluation of learning methods in an open-minded, yet skeptical manner that demands evidence.
Remember to check out the following resources from Dr. Thalheimer:
And don’t forget to check the other articles that came from this series of interviews with Dr. Thalheimer:
Finally, check out our own articles on Evidence-Based Training Practices and Learning Myths.
If you enjoyed this series of articles featuring Dr. Thalheimer, check out our earlier article featuring Arun Pradhan on the importance of learning to learn, and watch for some upcoming series with other exciting and leading learning professionals.
See you next time!
Learn what you need to know BEFORE you begin your search and get a free checklist to guide you, too.